Saturday, November 21, 2009
6 of 29 stories

Letter from Angel Canyon: Coyotes

November 4, 2009 : 8:31 AM ET

Into the wild

Into the wild

My wife, my dog, and I had come around a bend in the mouth of Pugh Canyon, and there she was, frozen scared inside a wash that seeped down the side of Vermillion Cliffs. The coyote was much smaller than our hound McGarr. She dashed up the talus slope, hopping and leaping with the ease and dexterity of jackrabbit. In a matter of about a minute, she had gained about 500 feet in elevation before disappearing behind the fallen boulders.

In the two and a half years I’ve lived in Kanab, this was only the second time I’d seen a coyote in the area. The first time occurred the year before in the same Pugh Canyon, which is located on the edge of Kanab, six or so miles south of Angel Canyon. That first encounter played out similarly, with the coyote fleeing into hiding soon after spotting us.

Both times I was struck by how small the animals were, and how handsome. Both had bushy tails, and a coat that spanned a color spectrum, from yellow to brown to red to black. Not at all did they fit the acculturated image I’d previously had of them, of being mangy, gaunt, menacing. If anything, they seemed terrified of our presence.

Beyond their pleasing aesthetics and their plaintive cries at night, I appreciate coyotes for their ability to thwart a multi-generational, state and federally sponsored effort by livestock producers, gun fanatics and USDA’s Wildlife Services to control, if not decimate their populations. In spite of those efforts, the species is today North America’s most ubiquitous natural predator, living in every continental American state and every Canadian province, as adaptable to Manhattan as Montana. Around southern Utah, there are coyotes galore, but they generally remain elusive, their nighttime howling discourses one of few indications we are in their midst.

Last spring, my wife and I could no longer hike the length of Pugh Canyon anymore. It wasn’t our decision — it was our dog’s. At some point, McGarr refused to go any farther than a quarter of a mile or so up the canyon (with still another mile to go before we usually turned around). No cajoling or leash pulling could change his mind. I could think of no explanation for it, not until learning of the attacks.

Natural beauty

Natural beauty

This fall, in two separate instances and two different locations on the outskirts of Kanab, a coyote attacked a dog, both times while their people were walking them. One dog barely survived. The other, sadly, didn’t.

The dog who survived was a terrier mix named Ziggy. As reported in The Salt Lake Tribune, Ziggy was out for a walk in Pugh Canyon with her person Ruthie Itow. Ziggy ran ahead and out of sight. After an unsuccessful search, Itow returned to her car, where she ran into a couple she knew who were on their way up the canyon. Itow asked them to keep a look out for Ziggy.

They did find Ziggy, and it was almost too late. The couple tried to scare the coyote off, but he wouldn’t let the dog go. So the woman grabbed the coyote by his scruff, kicked and fought him, and finally sent him fleeing, but not without getting bitten (thankfully, she was wearing a thick coat and was spared from any wounds). Itow rushed Ziggy to Best Friends’ clinic, where a team led by Dr. Mike Dix managed to save him.

I was surprised, but not shocked when I heard the news. Coyotes are opportunistic hunters — and lone ones often desperate, taking what they can, when they can. What surprised me was that they had attacked in such close proximity to people.

But as I learned from Best Friends’ wildlife rehabilitator Carmen Smith, it’s not so unusual for coyotes to act abnormally in the fall, the time of year when juvenile coyotes disperse from their pack in search of their own territory.

“They’re young, they’re bold, and they’re not yet wise,” Smith says. In other words, they have yet to learn a healthy fear of people.

After the attacks, there was, understandably, some measure of panic around town, with insinuation that if we continued to walk our dogs in the desert around Kanab, we would be subjecting not just our pets to peril, but ourselves as well.

Calm, I think, has prevailed, but the incidents have left us with a healthy reminder to keep our dogs on a leash or at least within eyesight while walking them in the wild. It’s also left us with an even healthier respect for the unpredictability of the wild, which the coyote so provocatively embodies and represents.

“Coyotes are no reason you can’t be out enjoying nature,” Smith says. I agree. The coyote are one of the reasons we should be out enjoying nature.

Click here to download a guide to coexisting with coyotes, with some important tips on what to do should you encounter one.

Written by Ted Brewer
Photos by Gary Kalpakoff

As part of Best Friends’ 25th anniversary in 2009, our goal is to double our membership, so we can double our efforts to bring about a time when all companion animals have a forever home. What can you do to help? Give the Gift of a Best Friends membership to family and friends.

Comments?
Comments?

Log in to Post a Comment

November 21, 2009 : 11:56 AM ET
posted by: Lifer
As an animal lover I see both sides of this story as I do not want coyotes killed indiscriminately. We need to keep our pets safe from what they do -eat other animals. That being said I would never venture out without a sidearm to prevent such attacks. I have a very small dog and would keep her on a leash in any area where predators are lurking. But should one come looking for a free meal-it would end there.


November 11, 2009 : 9:32 AM ET
posted by: chattykatty
No problem, Glennwood400. The important thing is Ziggy is still recovering but doing very well. Everyone lived to tell about it, lessons were learned and even the coyote is still free to live his life as nature intended.


November 10, 2009 : 5:30 PM ET
posted by: jeannemodesitt
Ziggy is doing very well! Ruthie is so happy with Ziggy's recovery. BF, I loved you before, but after the wonderful work you did for Ziggy, I love you beyond words.


November 10, 2009 : 3:38 PM ET
posted by: Glenwood400
I am sorry chattycathy. I did not know the whole story. Did not know they were taking their other dogs to the car to resume their search. See I spoke before I knew everything. I am very sorry that this happened to the dog. The owners must be devistated so I hope the dog recovers. Sorry.


November 8, 2009 : 6:34 PM ET
posted by: jenna w
When you say things like "we weren't there" you are just making excuses for poor judgement. I would not take my two dogs off leash there and I would be keeping close watch of the surroundings at all times. I wouldn't take more than two dogs either since that is all I could handle if something went wrong.

We call our animals our fur kids so what kind of parent would allow their child to run off out of site in the wild where there are animals that want to eat them?

Please note that comments allow all to voice their opinion. While this does not mean everyone will agree, it does mean that comments come from a basis of kindness and compassion. Comments that incite or can be construed as verbally attacking another will be censored.


November 8, 2009 : 12:26 PM ET
posted by: marys
Excellent answer Chattycatty. Can you imagine the chaos that would have ensued had Ruthie found Ziggy like that with her dogs in tow? Returning her other dogs to her car was the smart thing to do!! I know one of the first thoughts I would have had while searching for Ziggy was that he had gone back to the car upon realizing he was lost. Jeanne and Robin deserve some kind of award!! They not only volunteer at the sanctuary on a regular basis, but now are rescuers extraordinaire!! Thanks is not enough, but I thank them daily. Blessings to Dr. Mike and the whole Clinic staff for all you did for Ziggy. I can't help but feel sad for the coyotes who are just doing what they do for survival. The danger they represent deserves our attention and respect.


November 7, 2009 : 7:10 PM ET
posted by: chattykatty
To answer your question, Ziggy is elderly and deaf, rescued from an abussive situation. She was on an off-leash walk with the rest of her pack and her human and wandered off. Her human tried desperatly to find her and had returned her other dogs to the car and was resuming her search when Jeanne and her husband arrived. Off-leash walks are common in that area and Ruthie's dogs (including Ziggy) were accustomed to hiking in this canyon on a daily basis. This was not a situation where a human abandoned her dog in the midst of a coyote attack. The coyote attacked after Ziggy wandered away from her pack, unbeknown to her human.

Might we question whether a deaf, elderly dog should have been walking off leash? Maybe. But when this has been their habit for years and without incident, why would they change? It's easy to second-guess when we weren't there and aren't familiar with the situation.


November 5, 2009 : 2:55 PM ET
posted by: Glenwood400
After rereading the coyote story, I don't really understand why the people that owned the poor little dog that was almost killed, left it and went back to their car. If the people they met hadn't found the dog in time it would probably be dead and if they had kept looking for it, they might have saved it from being injured so bad. I could not leave my pet, but maybe I am being too judgemental.


November 5, 2009 : 12:21 PM ET
posted by: TTofer
Jeanne, thank you for seeing this from the coyote's point of view. There have always been animals that make their living by eating other animals, and always will be, and there's absolutely no reason to condemn them for it. (I could go off on a rant about people who feed their cats processed chicken in a can and then are absolutely horrified when they see the cat eating a mouse, but I'll refrain.)


November 4, 2009 : 8:19 PM ET
posted by: jeannemodesitt
I am the woman that rescued Ziggy from the coyote. My husband Robin and I regularly hike Pugh Canyon, and before the Ziggy incident, we had been seeing lots of coyotes along the trail that leads up Pugh Canyon. In the nine years we've lived here, we had never seen so many coyotes. The coyote that was eating Ziggy was young and very, very thin. I ran up to him while he was eating Ziggy, and the look in his eyes was one of intense hunger. He did not want to leave his prey, and that is why I had to be somewhat aggressive in getting him to leave Ziggy. As I told the townspeople, I was the one who attacked the coyote, not the other way around. (Yes, he acted aggressively toward me, but only because he didn't want to leave his meal.) A few days after the Ziggy episode, I walked back into Pugh Canyon, to the spot where the coyote was eating Ziggy, and I told the coyote, wherever he was, that I was so sorry I had to take away his meal, as I knew he was very hungry, but I had to rescue Ziggy because Ziggy was someone's (Ruthie's) baby. Best Friends was amazing in all that they did for Ziggy. Ziggy had a lot of flesh eaten (including her tail) and had to undergo many surgeries. She had to stay at the clinic for almost 3 weeks. The whole time, she received loving care from BF, and I am profoundly grateful for that. ZIggy has been home for about a week now, and is one happy dog. She will always be disabled (she has an entire flank missing) but she is not in pain, and THAT is a miracle.


November 4, 2009 : 3:16 PM ET
posted by: watsonsmom
What a great article; we have recently had highly public incidents with coyotes (in one, a homeless person had his toe bitten, and then Jessica Simpson's dog was taken presumably, by coyotes) where I hike in Griffith Park, Los Angeles, the result was the parks departments decision to shoot and kill 8 coyotes!!! I was horrified. I am sure we can learn to live with these amazing creatures, but we need to learn respect.


November 4, 2009 : 2:01 PM ET
posted by: Glenwood400
This is a scary story about the coyotes especially with the well know story of Jessica Simpson's beloved dog getting killed by coyotes and a young naturalist who was on a nature hike getting killed by two coyotes in Canada. This seems to be happening more and more and people must be cautious and keep their animals close and maybe not be alone in the wilderness because wild animals are wild.